Skip to Main content Skip to Navigation
Poster communications

Oil palm dreams and disillusions : smallhoders' plantations in a context of low inputs farming systems in Indonesia

Abstract : In Sumatra Island, in Indonesia, rubber plantations are a long tradition of familiy farming. The successes of oil palm smallholders involved in partnerships with companies ('plasma smallholders') worked as an incentive for the develoment of independent smallholders' plantations, most often replacing smallholders' old rubber agroforests and plantations. In Feintrenie et al. (2010) oil palm independent smallholders' plantations are expected to produce higher return to labour than rubber plantations, and more or less equivalent return to land depending on the respective prices of these two commodities. However, this result relies on assumptions on the yields of oil palm plantations that were generally too young to be productive at the time when the research was carried out. Is the reality at the level of expectations ? Are oil palm independent smallholders' plantations more profitable than rubber ones ? This paper challenges this assertion, and proposes an updated comparison between oil palm and rubber independent smallholders' plantations. We carried out interviews with independent oil palm smallholders in Jambi provinces in 2013. The Livelihoods of these regions relies mainly on low inputs rubber farming systems. Since 2000, several farmers have replaced rubber agroforests and plantations with oil palm plantations. We collected data on oil palm and rubber agricultural practices and calculated their respective profitability. We then compared oil palm plantations and rubber plantations net returns to smallholders depending on tow production factors : planting materials quality and fertilizers application quantity. Independent smallholders do not benefit from partnerships scheme advantages such as the provision of inputs and technical advices, but rather rely on themselves to access to necessary oil palm inputs. Our study showed that most of the fully independent farmers who tried oil palm have a poor access to selected seedlings and fertilizers. This lack of inputs quality impacts greatly fresh fruit bunches (FFB) production and thus reduces oil palm net returns for independent smallholders compared with plasma smallholders. In these agronomical conditions the production of oil palm FFB is not economically competitive with natural rubber production. Thus, in a context of low inputs farming systems, oil palm plantations can be less profitable than rubber plantations and cannot sustain farmers' livelihoods.
Document type :
Poster communications
Complete list of metadata
Contributor : Migration Prodinra Connect in order to contact the contributor
Submitted on : Friday, June 5, 2020 - 11:22:09 AM
Last modification on : Thursday, October 28, 2021 - 10:54:02 AM


Files produced by the author(s)


  • HAL Id : hal-02794467, version 1
  • PRODINRA : 271994



Margot Moulin, Laurène Feintrenie, Cécile Bessou, Julie Wohlfahrt. Oil palm dreams and disillusions : smallhoders' plantations in a context of low inputs farming systems in Indonesia. 4. International Conference on Oil Palm and Environment : Oil Palm Cultivation : Becoming a Model for Tomorrow's Sustainable Agriculture, 2014, Bali, Indonesia. 1 p., 2014. ⟨hal-02794467⟩



Record views


Files downloads