Skip to Main content Skip to Navigation
Journal articles

A simulation study of a honeybee breeding scheme accounting for polyandry, direct and maternal effects on colony performance

Abstract : Background: Efficient breeding programs are difficult to implement in honeybees due to their biological specificities (polyandry and haplo-diploidy) and complexity of the traits of interest, with performances being measured at the colony scale and resulting from the joint effects of tens of thousands of workers (called direct effects) and of the queen (called maternal effects). We implemented a Monte Carlo simulation program of a breeding plan designed specifically for Apis mellifera's populations to assess the impact of polyandry versus monoandry on colony performance, inbreeding level and genetic gain depending on the individual selection strategy considered, i.e. complete mass selection or within-family (maternal lines) selection. We simulated several scenarios with different parameter setups by varying initial genetic variances and correlations between direct and maternal effects, the selection strategy and the polyandry level. Selection was performed on colony phenotypes. Results: All scenarios showed strong increases in direct breeding values of queens after 20 years of selection. Monoandry led to significantly higher direct than maternal genetic gains, especially when a negative correlation between direct and maternal effects was simulated. However, the relative increase in these genetic gains depended also on their initial genetic variability and on the selection strategy. When polyandry was simulated, the results were very similar with either 8 or 16 drones mated to each queen. Across scenarios, polyandrous mating resulted in equivalent or higher gains in performance than monoandrous mating, but with considerably lower inbreeding rates. Mass selection conferred a ~ 20% increase in performance compared to within-family selection, but was also accompanied by a strong increase in inbreeding levels (25 to 50% higher). Conclusions: Our study is the first to compare the long-term effects of polyandrous versus monoandrous mating in honeybee breeding. The latter is an emergent strategy to improve specific traits, such as resistance to varroa, which can be difficult or expensive to phenotype. However, if used during several generations in a closed population, monoandrous mating increases the inbreeding level of queens much more than polyandrous mating, which is a strong limitation of this strategy.
Document type :
Journal articles
Complete list of metadata
Contributor : Tristan Kistler <>
Submitted on : Thursday, September 9, 2021 - 2:09:15 PM
Last modification on : Monday, September 13, 2021 - 9:52:55 AM


Kistler et al. A simulation st...
Publisher files allowed on an open archive


Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License



Tristan Kistler, Benjamin Basso, Florence Phocas. A simulation study of a honeybee breeding scheme accounting for polyandry, direct and maternal effects on colony performance. Genetics Selection Evolution, BioMed Central, 2021, 53, ⟨10.1186/s12711-021-00665-8⟩. ⟨hal-03339391⟩



Record views


Files downloads