The Plasma membrane Cation binding Protein 1 (PCaP1) has been shown to be important for the intra-cellular movement of two members of the Potyvirus genus in arabidopsis and tobacco plants. In this study, the orthologous PCaP1 gene of pepper (Capsicum annuum) was examined for its role in the accumulation of Potato virus Y, type member of the Potyvirus. Downregulation of C. annuum PCaP (CaPCaP) through tobacco rattle virus-induced gene silencing, resulted in lower accumulation of potato virus Y (PVY) in pepper plants. Using an improved pepper protoplast isolation protocol, we showed that knockdown of CaPCaP negatively affected PVY accumulation at the within-cell level in pepper in contrast with the turnip mosaic virus-arabidopsis pathosystem. Conversely, following overexpression of CaPCaP, the accumulation of PVY at the systemic level was increased. The results provide further knowledge on the role of PCaP in the potyvirus infection process and reveal differences of its action among different pathosystems.