The phylogeny of the hard tick genus Amblyomma Koch, 1844 deserves special attention, because several poorly studied tick species associated with reptiles still bear the name of this genus, although they may not belong to it. This study focuses on the phylogeny of two such species with uncertain taxonomic status, i.e., Amblyomma transversale (Lucas, 1845) and Amblyomma exornatum Koch, 1844, analyzing two mitochondrial (cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 and 16S rRNA) and two nuclear (18S and 28S rRNA) genes. In the cox1 phylogenetic analysis, both Am. transversale and Am. exornatum were part of a sister group to all other Metastriata, whereas in the 16S rRNA gene analysis, Am. transversale belonged to a sister group to three subfamilies (Amblyomminae Neumann, 1911; Haemaphysalinae Hoogstraal and Aeschlimann, 1982; Bothriocrotoninae Klompen, Dobson and Baker, 2002), and Am. exornatum formed a sister group to other Amblyomminae. However, based on the 18S and 28S rRNA genes, Am. transversale belonged to a sister group of either Bothriocrotoninae alone or of both Bothriocrotoninae and Haemaphysalinae, respectively. In the latter two phylogenetic analyses Am. exornatum always clustered within Amblyomminae. Morphological comparisons revealed that Am. transversale has at least four unique characters and shares a high number of traits with the genera Robertsicus Barker and Burger, 2018 and Archaeocroton Barker and Burger, 2018, as well as with the subgenus Alloceraea Schulze, 1918 (represented by Haemaphysalis inermis Birula, 1895). These results justify that the genus Africaniella Travassos Dias, 1974 should be reinstated, and the species name of Am. transversale should be used as Africaniella transversale (Lucas, 1845).