The origin of N isotopic discrimination and its relationship with feed efficiency in fattening yearling bulls is diet-dependent - INRAE - Institut national de recherche pour l’agriculture, l’alimentation et l’environnement Access content directly
Journal Articles PLoS ONE Year : 2020

The origin of N isotopic discrimination and its relationship with feed efficiency in fattening yearling bulls is diet-dependent


Nitrogen (N) isotopic discrimination (i.e. the difference in natural N-15 abundance between the animal proteins and the diet; Delta N-15) is known to correlate with N use efficiency (NUE) and feed conversion efficiency (FCE) in ruminants. However, results from the literature are not always consistent across studies, likely due to isotopic discrimination pathways that may differ with the nature of diets. The objective of the present study was to assess at which level, from rumen to tissues, Delta N-15 originates and becomes related to NUE and FCE in fattening yearling bulls when they are fed two contrasted diets. Twenty-four Charolais yearling bulls were randomly divided into two groups and fed during 8 months, from weaning to slaughter, either 1) a high starch diet based on corn silage supplying a balanced N to energy ratio at the rumen level (starch) or 2) a high fiber diet based on grass silage supplying an excess of rumen degradable N (fiber). All animals were slaughtered and samples of different digestive pools (ruminal, duodenal, ileal and fecal contents), animal tissues (duodenum, liver and muscle), blood and urine were collected for each animal. Ruminal content was further used to isolate liquid-associated bacteria (LAB), protozoa and free ammonia, while plasma proteins were obtained from blood. All samples along with feed were analyzed for their N isotopic composition. For both diets, the digestive contribution (i.e. the N isotopic discrimination occurring before absorption) to the Delta N-15 observed in animal tissues accounted for 65 +/- 11%, leaving only one third to the contribution of post-absorptive metabolism. Concerning the Delta N-15 in digestive pools, the majority of these changes occurred in the rumen (av. Delta N-15 = 2.12 +/- 0.66 parts per thousand), with only minor N-15 enrichments thereafter (av. Delta N-15 = 2.24 +/- 0.41 parts per thousand), highlighting the key role of the rumen on N isotopic discrimination. A strong, significant overall relationship (n = 24) between Delta N-15 and FCE or NUE was found when using any post-absorptive metabolic pool (duodenum, liver, or muscle tissues, or plasma proteins; 0.52 < r < 0.73; P <= 0.01), probably as these pools reflect both digestive and post-absorptive metabolic phenomena. Fiber diet compared to starch diet had a lower feed efficiency and promoted higher (P <= 0.05) Delta N-15 values across all post-absorptive metabolic pools and some digestive pools (ruminal, duodenal, and ileal contents). The within-diet relationship (n = 12) between Delta N-15 and feed efficiency was not as strong and consistent as the overall relationship, with contrasted responses between the two diets for specific pools (diet x pool interaction; P <= 0.01). Our results highlight the contrasted use of N at the rumen level between the two experimental diets and suggests the need for different equations to predict FCE or NUE from Delta N-15 according to the type of diet. In conclusion, rumen digestion and associated microbial activity can play an important role on N isotopic discrimination so rumen effect related to diet may interfere with the relationship between Delta N-15 and feed efficiency in fattening yearling bulls.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
a761cbee2708f1c6d3ff65369a8529d0.pdf (1.03 Mo) Télécharger le fichier
Origin : Files produced by the author(s)

Dates and versions

hal-02850879 , version 1 (01-04-2024)



Sayyed Mahmoud Nasrollahi, Sarah Jade Meale, Diego Morgavi, Anne-Marie Schiphorst, Richard Robins, et al.. The origin of N isotopic discrimination and its relationship with feed efficiency in fattening yearling bulls is diet-dependent. PLoS ONE, 2020, 15 (6), pp.e0234344. ⟨10.1371/journal.pone.0234344⟩. ⟨hal-02850879⟩
41 View
6 Download



Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More