Nature is harnessed since ancient times to fulfill human needs, and yeast culture has been mastered for bakery, brewery, or the preparation of beverages. In this context, the two recently discovered yeast species Starmerella reginensis and Starmerella kourouensis, belonging to a genus related to fermentative activities in the literature, were explored via untargeted metabolomics approaches. Ultrahigh-performance liquid chromatography hyphenated with tandem mass spectrometry and a deep investigation of molecular networks and spectral data allowed the annotation of, respectively, 439 and 513 metabolites for S. reginensis and S. kourouensis, with approximatively 30% compound annotations and 40% chemical class annotations for both yeast strains. These analyses and Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry accurate metabolic profiles unveiled a rich content of alkaloids, lipids, amino acids, and terpenoids for S. reginensis. S. kourouensis presents a similar profile with more sulfated compounds. In short, these results enrich the current knowledge about Starmerella yeast secondary metabolites and reveal their significant structural diversity of small molecules.