What is the current state of green farming? Logics of diversification and implications for transition
Résumé
More than 10 years ago, we highlighted the paradigmatic and institutional dynamics of the emergence and development of various proposals for ecologised agriculture in
academia and beyond (Ollivier and Bellon, 2013). Since then, agroecology, 'climate-smart agriculture', regenerative agriculture and digital agriculture have all been added to the already rich landscape of these proposals (sustainable agriculture, organic agriculture, precision agriculture, etc.).
Our aim is to show and understand the diversification dynamics of ecological farming. On the one hand, what is it the product of? We will show that the social mechanisms of appropriation, redifferentiation and even capture (Giraldo and Rosset, 2017; Lamine et al., 2019) continually generate new proposals and reclassifications of existing forms,
announcing environmental or social improvements (Bellon and Ollivier, 2018). These ecologised agricultures refer to differentiated framings of problems and solutions
(Therond et al., 2017). For example, the 'soil is the key to everything' narrative or investment in robotics obscures certain compartments of the socio-eco-technological
system, favours different associated environments (Simondon, 1989) and builds new path dependencies. The diversity of forms of ecologised agriculture thus reveals
preferential attachments to social actors, strategies of distinction (Ollivier and Bellon, 2013) and distinct values (Plumecocq et al., 2018).
Finally, we would like to discuss the implications of this diversity for the ecological transition of agriculture. Firstly, we are witnessing competition and controversy between
forms, for example in terms of access to public support, to the market through product labelling, or to agricultural advice and expertise. This profusion also generates polysemy and even confusion among citizens, consumers, researchers and professionals, obscuring dialogue and consensus-building on the transition paths to follow.
Finally, under these conditions, the ongoing diversification of forms of agriculture forces us to devote a great deal of energy to legitimisation tests (Montenegro de Wit and Iles, 2016), and to constantly redefine the perimeter of these forms. Finally, although the status quo in favour of unsustainable forms of agriculture predominates, ecologised forms of agriculture have the burden of proof as to whether they are really better.
Fichier principal
2024_2_1_1%2848%29%20-%20St%C3%A9phane%20Bellon%20%28EN%29.pdf (187.35 Ko)
Télécharger le fichier
Origine | Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s) |
---|