Many factors, such as the farming systems and preslaughter rearing practices, can influence the physiological and metabolic functions of poultry with consequent effects on poultry meat quality. In this trial, label-free shotgun proteomics was used to analyze the early post-mortem Pectoralis major muscle proteomes of Ross 308 and Ranger Classic chicken strains raised under two divergent farming systems these being organic and antibiotic-free. The combination of chemometrics using partial-least-square discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) and shotgun proteomics allowed clear discrimination between the different groups. Chicken strains were discriminated by differences in the abundance of 73 and 62 proteins within the antibiotic-free and organic farming systems, respectively. The abundances of 71 and 52 proteins were impacted by the farming system within the Ross 308 and Ranger Classic chicken strains, respectively. The analyses allowed for the proposal of several putative biomarkers of meat authenticity, which were found to be related to muscle structure and energy metabolism pathways. This study is a significant step forward in elucidating the potential of proteomics profiling and chemometrics in chicken meat, which may provide opportunities for the efficient assessment of chicken authenticity.